Cass Report Author Questions Workability of Conversion Practices Bill
The author of the independent review into gender identity services for young people, Baroness Cass, has expressed doubts about the current draft bill aiming to ban conversion practices. While previously supporting it, she stated on BBC Radio 4's Today program that the bill, in its current form, is not workable.
She further warned it might lead to "serious unintended consequences" for parents of children experiencing gender distress and medical professionals working in this field.
A government spokesperson acknowledged her comments, assuring they would carefully consider all evidence presented during the parliamentary committee scrutinizing the bill. They emphasized their goal of "getting this ban right".
The draft legislation, introduced in June, defines conversion practices as interventions intended to change sexual orientation or gender identity, often occurring in religious or family settings and can be extremely distressing.
Baroness Cass initially welcomed the bill, but now raises concerns about potential misuse of the legislation and its impact on families. She specifically points to the risk of prosecution for professionals and parents acting in good faith.
She cites the bill's wording, which requires proof of "serious harm" or "substantial adverse effect," as potentially leading to "vexatious" complaints against therapists treating gender-distressed youth. She also expresses worry about the chilling effect on professionals and families, fearing potential prosecution for actions that might otherwise be considered appropriate.
When questioned about her previous support, Baroness Cass explained she was in favor of the concept but hadn't had time to review the bill's details before her quote was released. She emphasized her continued belief that no LGBTQ+ individual should face conversion practices.