New York City Considers Banning Horse-Drawn Carriages: A Controversial Tradition
BBC Homepage
Skip to content Accessibility Help
Your account
Home News ... (rest of the navigation)
New York City is reevaluating a classic attraction: the horse-drawn carriage. Are they a necessary part of the city's landscape or a form of abuse on innocent animals?
Image caption: Drivers of horse-drawn carriages in Central Park are concerned for their future while animal activists see a ban as victory.
By Madeline Halpert
In Central Park, New York City
Published 5 hours ago
After a personal encounter with a carriage horse at the age of five, Alexus Lawson has driven one for six years in Central Park. However, a recent vote to ban the carriages due to animal and public safety concerns has left her worried.
"What am I supposed to do with my horse?" Lawson asks about her current horse, Starlight. "How am I supposed to ensure her health?"
Lawson is one of approximately 200 horse-drawn carriage drivers in Central Park. This over 160-year-old tradition, a popular tourist activity, could end in June 2028 with a City Council ban expected to pass on Thursday. Mayor Zohran Mamdani plans to aid in the transition for the industry's workers.
Drivers' Perspectives
Several drivers expressed skepticism towards the ban, disputing claims of horse abuse and insisting on their dedication to their animals. They argued that immediate action could be taken if safety was truly a concern.
"There were a few cases of horses dying in the middle of the park," said New York resident Ron Tsur, "You can clearly see that they're not taken care of."
Since 1982, 40 horse deaths in Central Park have been attributed to issues like overheating and collisions, according to the Manhattan Borough President's office.
A History of Ban Attempts
New York leaders previously attempted to ban the carriages under pressure from animal rights activists, but faced resistance from City Council members and unions representing the drivers.
However, this summer, the ban movement gained renewed momentum after a series of incidents.
In June, Romanch Mahajan, a tourist from India, was killed when the horse he was riding bolted, highlighting the risks involved. The proposed ban, named Romanch's Law, also follows the death of a carriage horse, Deniz, who consumed a toxic plant in Central Park this year.
The Drivers' Defense
Drivers like Lawson argue that the carriages are well-regulated and that horses are treated humanely. They believe an immediate ban would be harsh, especially considering the transition challenges for the horses.
The Central Park Conservancy, which supports the ban, reported seven "horse-related incidents" over the past 13 months, including a driver hospitalized after a spooked horse caused a carriage to tip over in May and a horse running into traffic in January, leading to a multi-car collision.
Lawson, who owns six horses, maintains that horse-drawn carriages are a vital part of New York City's history and tourism, and that the city's concerns could be better addressed through immediate action and improved regulations rather than a two-year phase-out.